develooper Front page | perl.perl6.users | Postings from March 2023

Re: Undefine mixed data

Thread Previous | Thread Next
Polgár Márton
March 21, 2023 22:28
Re: Undefine mixed data
Message ID:
If you made actual evidential arguments why it's good that Nil gets fed 
into @variables on assignment, or why is it good that @variables are, 
yes, both defined and DEFINITE when only declared, why this 
inconsistency, or counterpointing design,with $variables, is a good 
thing, we could discuss that.

However, you didn't, so now I'm left with personal impressions. You seem 
like the kind of user that Perl 6 should have never created: a user who 
is desperately willing to fix themselves when the language is shaking. I 
think replicating this mentality, i.e teaching people that they just 
have to learn harder, every single time they have a sensible and 
consistent complaint about the language, is much more dangerous than 
planting the thought that, as promised, Perl 6 made new mistakes, as 
opposed to the old Perl 5 mistakes. I think it's only fair that if I 
demonstrate a problem, building upon the experience of others, and point 
out a direction in which it could be improved, then that's legitimate 
impact. Really, let people think that there is a big broad problem in 
Raku's design - which is not a unique thing among programming languages 
really; part of the reason there is so many of them! - , and give them 
ways to cope, and hope for improvements. For the people, that's 
healthier than recognizing the problem nevertheless, but finding out 
that it's denied.

You probably know that Nil is far from being two decades old, or the 
Great List Refactor. These are things that took place before the first 
official release but they were also much bigger changes than the one we 
are talking about. It *is *possible to change the language, and it is 
sometimes desirable as well.

For defined and DEFINITE - I think you are correct and I don't know 
myself how to properly explain it. Horribile dictu: I think this part of 
the language is overwhelmingly complicated, way beyond usefulness. But I 
don't think it's downright contradictory. Another example would be Empty 
which is clearly DEFINITE, yet not defined.

Anyway, it doesn't help us with the @variables that start from being 
both DEFINITE and defined while $variables start from being not DEFINITE 
and clearly not defined.

Thread Previous | Thread Next Perl Programming lists via nntp and http.
Comments to Ask Bjørn Hansen at | Group listing | About