develooper Front page | perl.perl5.porters | Postings from September 2009

"contributed by" in pod dir.

Thread Next
From:
Richard Foley
Date:
September 2, 2009 02:09
Subject:
"contributed by" in pod dir.
Message ID:
200909021110.33643.Richard.Foley@rfi.net
Hi folks,

I don't know if it's necessary for an author to "sign off" each and every line he contributes to the pod, but it sure makes for 
rather stilted reading of the pod dir, and has the insidious side-effect of implying no-one else has contributed to the the 
original material over the last 15 years.  It seems to me that, besides the core Authors/Changes listing, an Author section for a 
major document, and/or a credit where something substantial was undertaken/changed/contributed is quite reasonable naturally, but 
the majority of the continual "contributed by..." below, for each additional paragraph in the FAQs, really feels 
like unnecessary trumpet blowing, and we remove them, please.  Does anyone else feel this way, or is this just an irrational 
reaction on my part about which one should remain respectfully silent?  These 96 (!) mostly ->duplicated<- entries are what I'm 
talking about:

$> cd pod/

$> grep contributed *pod | wc
     96     592    4953

$> grep contributed *pod
perl5100delta.pod:This feature was contributed by Robin Houston.
perl5101delta.pod:The other core committers contributed most of the changes, and applied most
perl5110delta.pod:The other core committers contributed most of the changes, and applied most
perl5110delta.pod:Much of the work of categorizing changes in this perldelta file was contributed
perl561delta.pod:Thanks are gladly extended to the many people who have contributed VMS
perl56delta.pod:Thanks are gladly extended to the many people who have contributed VMS
perl588delta.pod:C<File::Basename> upgraded to version 2.74, with changes contributed by Michael Schwern.
perl588delta.pod:contributed by Dave Mitchell which reworked the warnings code to be
perl589delta.pod:Andreas KE<ouml>nig contributed two functions to save and load the debugger
perl589delta.pod:been contributed by Yves Orton.
perl589delta.pod:(from RedHat) also contributed patches that complete the set of flags
perl589delta.pod:The other core committers contributed most of the changes, and applied most
perl593delta.pod:Those features, and the C<feature> pragma itself, have been contributed by
perlfaq1.pod:(contributed by brian d foy)
perlfaq1.pod:(contributed by brian d foy)
perlfaq1.pod:(contributed by brian d foy)
perlfaq1.pod:(contributed by brian d foy)
perlfaq1.pod:(contributed by brian d foy)
perlfaq1.pod:(contributed by brian d foy)
perlfaq2.pod:(contributed by brian d foy)
perlfaq2.pod:(contributed by brian d foy)
perlfaq3.pod:(contributed by brian d foy)
perlfaq3.pod:(contributed by brian d foy, updated Fri Jul 25 12:22:26 PDT 2008)
perlfaq3.pod:(contributed by brian d foy)
perlfaq3.pod:(contributed by Ben Morrow)
perlfaq3.pod:(contributed by Michael Carman)
perlfaq3.pod:(contributed by brian d foy)
perlfaq3.pod:[Some of this answer was contributed by Kenneth Albanowski.]
perlfaq3.pod:(contributed by brian d foy)
perlfaq4.pod:(contributed by brian d foy)
perlfaq4.pod:(contributed by brian d foy)
perlfaq4.pod:(contributed by brian d foy and Dave Cross)
perlfaq4.pod:(contributed by brian d foy)
perlfaq4.pod:   # contributed by Gunnar Hjalmarsson
perlfaq4.pod:(contributed by brian d foy)
perlfaq4.pod:(contributed by brian d foy)
perlfaq4.pod:(contributed by brian d foy)
perlfaq4.pod:(contributed by brian d foy)
perlfaq4.pod:(contributed by brian d foy)
perlfaq4.pod:(contributed by brian d foy)
perlfaq4.pod:(contributed by brian d foy)
perlfaq4.pod:(contributed by brian d foy)
perlfaq4.pod:(contributed by brian d foy)
perlfaq4.pod:(portions of this answer contributed by Anno Siegel and brian d foy)
perlfaq4.pod:(contributed by brian d foy)
perlfaq4.pod:(contributed by brian d foy)
perlfaq4.pod:(contributed by brian d foy)
perlfaq4.pod:(contributed by brian d foy)
perlfaq4.pod:(contributed by brian d foy)
perlfaq4.pod:(contributed by brian d foy)
perlfaq4.pod:(contributed by brian d foy)
perlfaq4.pod:(contributed by brian d foy)
perlfaq4.pod:(contributed by brian d foy and Ben Morrow)
perlfaq4.pod:(contributed by Ben Morrow)
perlfaq5.pod:(contributed by brian d foy)
perlfaq5.pod:(contributed by brian d foy)
perlfaq5.pod:(contributed by brian d foy)
perlfaq5.pod:(contributed by Peter J. Holzer, hjp-usenet2@hjp.at)
perlfaq5.pod:(contributed by brian d foy and Benjamin Goldberg)
perlfaq5.pod:(contributed by Brian McCauley)
perlfaq5.pod:(contributed by brian d foy)
perlfaq5.pod:(contributed by brian d foy)
perlfaq5.pod:(contributed by brian d foy)
perlfaq5.pod:(contributed by Shlomi Fish)
perlfaq6.pod:(contributed by brian d foy)
perlfaq6.pod:(contributed by brian d foy)
perlfaq6.pod:(contributed by brian d foy)
perlfaq6.pod:( contributed by brian d foy )
perlfaq6.pod:(contributed by brian d foy)
perlfaq6.pod:(contributed by Anno Siegel)
perlfaq6.pod:(contributed by brian d foy)
perlfaq7.pod:(contributed by brian d foy)
perlfaq7.pod:(contributed by brian d foy)
perlfaq7.pod:(contributed by brian d foy)
perlfaq7.pod:(contributed by brian d foy)
perlfaq7.pod:(contributed by brian d foy)
perlfaq7.pod:(contributed by brian d foy)
perlfaq7.pod:(contributed by brian d foy)
perlfaq7.pod:(contributed by brian d foy)
perlfaq8.pod:(contributed by brian d foy)
perlfaq8.pod:(contributed by brian d foy)
perlfaq8.pod:(contributed by brian d foy)
perlfaq8.pod:(contributed by brian d foy)
perlfaq8.pod:(contributed by Xho)
perlfaq8.pod:(answer contributed by brian d foy)
perlfaq8.pod:(contributed by brian d foy)
perlfaq8.pod:(contributed by brian d foy)
perlfaq9.pod:(contributed by brian d foy)
perlfaq9.pod:(contributed by brian d foy)
perlfaq9.pod:(contributed by brian d foy)
perlfaq9.pod:(contributed by brian d foy)
perlfaq9.pod:(partly contributed by Aaron Sherman)
perlfaq9.pod:(contributed by brian d foy)
perlfaq.pod:FAQ. Several people have contributed answers, corrections, and comments,
perltooc.pod:and Stephen Warren all contributed suggestions and corrections to this
perlxstut.pod:PerlIO material contributed by Lupe Christoph, with some clarification
$>

Mr unpopular-perl5-enthusiast sits down and ducks to avoid the incoming ICBMs!

--
Richard Foley
Ciao - shorter than aufwiedersehen

http://www.rfi.net/

Thread Next


nntp.perl.org: Perl Programming lists via nntp and http.
Comments to Ask Bjørn Hansen at ask@perl.org | Group listing | About