develooper Front page | perl.perl5.porters | Postings from February 2008

Re: [PATCH] feature bundles are the same across all subversions

Thread Previous
Rafael Garcia-Suarez
February 8, 2008 01:45
Re: [PATCH] feature bundles are the same across all subversions
Message ID:
On 13/01/2008, Steffen Mueller <> wrote:
> Hi p5p,
> with this patch, all feature bundles with different sub-versions are
> made equal:
>    use feature ':5.10.0';
> then is the same as
>    use feature ':5.10';
> This fixes the issue Rafael brought up that 5.12.0 croaks on
>    use feature ':5.10.5';
> if 5.10.5 was released after 5.12.0 eventhough it seems natural to
> assume that "5.12.0" > "5.10.5".

Thanks, applied as #33247.

> Please note that I'm not entirely in favour of having this patch
> applied. The recent discussion about backporting features was going in
> this direction and currently, this is the only proposed way to fix the
> problem entirely. It seems to me that any other fix would include
> dual-living feature and expecting all users to stay on the bleeding edge
> with that. (Suuure...) For details on that, please refer to the recent
> thread.

Another solution would be to devise some heuristic. I couldn't find a
way to do that without permitting inconsistent behaviours. So for now
we, by contract, ensure there are no new features added in maintenance

Thread Previous Perl Programming lists via nntp and http.
Comments to Ask Bjørn Hansen at | Group listing | About