develooper Front page | perl.perl5.porters | Postings from April 2000

Re: PATCH: perlre.pod (against 5.6.0)

April 29, 2000 19:18
Re: PATCH: perlre.pod (against 5.6.0)
Message ID:
In <4576.957042210@chthon>, Tom Christiansen writes:
:>ll153-4: Otherwise, the lefter one always wins.
:>Cute though it is, I'd rather see something like 'the leftmost of the
:The problem with that, which I did consider, is that -most is in
:the superlative degree, something that cannot occur when merely two
:items are being compared.  For that, you need the comparative degree.

Otherwise, the one to the left always wins. ('starting to the left of
the other', in full.)

I think I understand why you've added this new paragraph, but I'm not
at all sure that it is the right thing to do - I think there is a
danger that it will make it more difficult for the gentle reader
later to understand how the backtracking mechanism (along with the
combinatorial rules of a few simple operators) entirely determine
which match is found. I have no replacement to offer, however.

:>l179: \u      titlecase next char
:>Not sure what 'titlecase' means, or why it is more accurate than
:>'uppercase', nor why \U was not similarly changed.
:Because that doesn't happen there.  "titlecase" is a Unicode notion.
:(It's somewhat misleading, since it doesn't really understand proper
:titlecasing rules in English.)  But some scripts (read: charsets)
:allegedly distinguish between these.  That's why toke.c has
:toUPPER_LC_uni for uc(), but toTITLE_LC_uni for ucfirst().

I think that's worth expanding on then: taking myself as the
epitome of the man on the Clapham omnibus, the reader will not
know what this word means until it is explained.

Hugo Perl Programming lists via nntp and http.
Comments to Ask Bjørn Hansen at | Group listing | About