develooper Front page | perl.perl5.porters | Postings from October 1999

Re: What the world really needs [was Detecting RedHat...]

From:
Joshua N Pritikin
Date:
October 27, 1999 07:00
Subject:
Re: What the world really needs [was Detecting RedHat...]
Message ID:
19991027095938.E3983@eq1062.wks.na.deuba.com
On Wed, Oct 27, 1999 at 09:38:02AM -0400, John.Redford@fmr.com wrote:
> You hint at the answer, but it is just a bit further. There is an essential
> unspoken question in the problem: Can you trust what you are told? For me,
> the answer is unambiguously 'no'. Linux says it is Unix, and it is not. AIX
> says it is Unix, and it is not. POSIX is not POSIX and SunOS is not SunOS. I
> do not believe that "the humans who built the thing" in fact "actually know
> what the answers are". Further, I am sure they know nothing about what is
> done with "the thing" when it is customized after they build it.

Amen!  Praise the lord!

> So you can never say "This is <XXX>" and say anything ultimately meaningful.
> However, you can say "This is this." Without regard to what any piece of
> documentation says, you have the system and can examine it. One may test the
> 'features' of the system empirically and compare the computed results with
> expectations. Then you have an accurate description of what you have ...

Agree 100%.

-- 
"Does `competition' have an abstract purpose?"
       via, but not speaking for Deutsche Bank



nntp.perl.org: Perl Programming lists via nntp and http.
Comments to Ask Bjørn Hansen at ask@perl.org | Group listing | About