develooper Front page | perl.module-authors | Postings from November 2011

Re: The CPAN Covenant

Thread Previous | Thread Next
From:
dhudes
Date:
November 28, 2011 21:17
Subject:
Re: The CPAN Covenant
Message ID:
387d41b715e23ad58096e1982d65a62f.squirrel@webmail.hudes.org
I've mostly ignored all this but I will step in briefly.
I am the author of a few modules on CPAN. None of them are major. The
dependency of one on another module which has been broken for years means
that I get frequent e-mail that it fails its tests. There's nothing wrong
with -my- module and if you actually force install it, you can use it.

Other stuff of mine is in the alpha, proof-of-concept stage as a set. The
code works in the sense that it doesn't die or anything -- the underlying
algorithm produces false positives and I've never gotten the time to work
on it (the HTTP::ADS was my PhD thesis proposal but I failed to get
funding, left the PhD program and took a real job). Pieces of it -do- work
(the proxy detector). I'm content to leave it out there as a 'publication'
and if someone else wants to use pieces of it go right ahead as long as I
am credited with authorship on my parts. I most vehemently resent anyone
deciding that my contributions are not worth keeping around. What if one
day the CGI::Untaint::Test module gets fixed and my various contributions
to CGI::Untaint pass their tests again? For that matter, what if I find
time to work on the HTTP::ADS again?

I have various sysadmin tools for DNS which I haven't finished the
documentation for but hope to get a chance to finish and contribute -- but
if my earlier efforts are deemed worthless, there is no way I would
contribute anything to CPAN ever again. Maybe you think that's an
insignificant loss -- but where is the harm to the community to leaving my
contributions where they are? Even if they aren't bug-free, I have tried
very hard to make them exemplary in coding and documentation (whether I
succeeded or not is for others to judge) so that they at least fill the
purpose of examples. I'm not Damian, but my job isn't to write free
software or books on Perl.



Thread Previous | Thread Next


nntp.perl.org: Perl Programming lists via nntp and http.
Comments to Ask Bjørn Hansen at ask@perl.org | Group listing | About